Marginal Scholarship and Textual Deviance: The Commentarium Cornuti and the Early Scholia on PersiusInstitute of Classical Studies, School of Advanced Study, University of London, 2005 - 241 strán (strany) The Satires of Persius combine powerful criticism of the moral corruption of Rome under Nero with a rich and innovative style that required commentary almost from his own time. The enduring appeal and originality of his poetry also ensured that the exegetical tradition has been continuous from the first century to the present. Marginal scholarship and textual deviance examines the origins and history of a major component of the medieval commentary on Persius but also has a larger goal. The volume uses detailed study of Carolingian exegesis of Persius to consider wider questions about the transmission and form of the remains of ancient scholarship on Latin poetry. Through these explorations James Zetzel also considers the nature of textual transmission and the goals of textual criticism in general. Medieval exegesis is one of the types of text for which post-modernist concerns about the stability of the concept of 'text' itself may legitimately arise. Marginal scholarship and textual deviance argues that there is often no 'original' to reconstruct no 'genuine' text and no one author: there is only variation and a broad range of mutually exclusive but complementary truths. What makes a commentary a commentary a text a text? Are there valid principles to be employed in defining and editing such works? This is an important and original study for all interested in the survival and transmission of texts in authorship and in reading. James E. G. Zetzel is Professor of Classics at Columbia University in the City of New York. |
Obsah
Scholia and Stemmatics 1 | 5 |
The Major Manuscripts of the Commentum | 14 |
The Later Tradition of the Commentum | 49 |
Autorské práva | |
9 zvyšných častí nezobrazených
Iné vydania - Zobraziť všetky
Marginal Scholarship and Textual Deviance: The Commentarium Cornuti and the ... James E. G. Zetzel Zobrazenie úryvkov - 2005 |
Časté výrazy a frázy
ancient apud autem BVin carmina Carolingian century cinaedi clear clearly commentary on Persius commentary on Satire Commentum Commentum Cornuti Cornutus cuius dicere dicitur dicta dicunt dicuntur dixit doublet eius enim erat ergo errors etiam facit fact fuit genus habet haec Heiric hinc hoc dicit homines hominum id est ideo idest illa inquit Isidore Jahn Juvenal KQPN Latin lemma sign major lemma manuscripts marginal scholia marginalia medieval MLUR omitted passage Persius Pierre Pithou Pithou poeta potest propter puteal quae quam quia quibus quid quod readings Remigius Rous RTBVin scholiastic scholium scilicet scribe sensus sentence Servius set of notes sicut solebant Solinus SPith stemmatic sunt supra tamen tantum text of Persius textual textual criticism tibi tradition tunc tuum uero uitia Vinet Wessner WOKQ words